Italian Arbitration Day 2026: Arbitration in the Age of Economic and Legal Disruption of Tariffs, Sanctions and Global Uncertainty
November 21, 2026
The fifth edition of the Italian Arbitration Day (“IAD”) was held in Rome on 11 June 2026, organised by the Milan Chamber of Arbitration and AIA (Associazione Italiana per l’Arbitrato). The conference focused on how international arbitration is adapting to an increasingly disrupted global environment, marked by geopolitical tensions, tariffs, sanctions, supply-chain disruptions and uncertainty affecting international trade and investment.
The Milan Chamber of Arbitration's Director General Stefano Azzali, the Associazione Italiana dell’Arbitrato’s President Andrea Carlevaris and Secretary General Maria Beatrice Deli opened the event, at the Campidoglio in Rome, facing the Eternal City’s ancient forum.
First Session’s Keynote Speech
Carlo Altomonte (Bocconi University) and Alain Pellet (Nanterre University) delivered their keynote speeches, each one highlighting the current geopolitical and economic international risk scenarios, providing an in-depth analysis combining macroeconomics and public international law to frame the global forces causing frictions and imbalances. Altomonte, approaching the topic from an economic perspective, described a transitional phase in which the post-Cold War framework is being redefined by the dominant power of the United States, with tariffs used as a negotiating tool. In such a scenario, globalization is far from over: multinational companies, whose assets grew from USD 300 billion in 1990 to USD 51 trillion in 2024, mitigate the disruption by reconfiguring their business strategies around geopolitical choke points. Pellet, from the standpoint of public international law, denounced a structural crisis marked by a constant erosion of the rule of law in favour of the use of force, the spread of unilateral sanctions and the weakening of multilateral treaty-making and dispute settlement.
Panel I - What Disputes?
The moderator Michele Potestà (Lévy Kaufmann-Kohler) introduced the first panel, which focused on emerging categories of disputes.
The principal risk areas identified for international arbitration were geopolitics, economic sanctions and digital transformation. He observed that disputes arising over the next decade will increasingly be shaped by governmental intervention, restrictive measures, and technological innovation. Arbitration will therefore be required to address issues extending beyond the traditional boundaries of contract law.
Constantine Partasides (Three Crowns LLP) addressed the transformation of investment protection. At a time when the traditional system of investment arbitration faces increasing criticism, he suggested a renewed appreciation for the role of investment contracts. Reference was made to the historical Texaco, BP, and LIAMCO cases. Attention was devoted to the evolution of stabilization clauses, from freezing clauses to economic equilibrium clauses.
Additional topics included contract claims, applicable law and arbitrations arising under the Energy Charter Treaty, addressing the legal issues raised by such claims and proceedings. Partasides noted that investment treaty arbitration is under attack, both on grounds of effectiveness and as a matter of principle, pointing to developments in Brussels. Should the treaty regime decline, he suggested, protection would shift back to contracts, as in the Libyan nationalization cases, where, in the absence of a BIT, the sole arbitrator in Texaco, appointed by the President of the ICJ, applied international law to the contract on the strength of its governing-law, economic development and stabilization clauses and found the nationalization to be an unlawful expropriation. He added that a recent tribunal applied stabilization clauses also to changes in the interpretation or application of unchanged legislation. He emphasized that economic equilibrium clauses preserve a state’s right to regulate provided the state compensates the investor, noting that contractual commitments are inherently harder to dispute than treaty obligations.
Aurélia Antonietti (ICSID) presented the current ICSID landscape and its experience with contract clauses, highlighting their geopolitical diversity and introducing the forthcoming publication of a new set of multistep model clauses.
Topics discussed included the continuing relevance of state-related contracts, ICSID practice, the growing use of multi-step procedures and the drafting of model clauses. She also focused on disputes arising from economic sanctions and cases in which the freezing of assets may be characterized as unlawful expropriation.
Turgut Aysan Özcan (Fırat Gültekin & Partners) examined disputes involving cryptocurrencies and digital assets. Arbitration was presented as a particularly suitable mechanism for resolving highly technical and transnational disputes. The speaker highlighted differences among regulatory approaches across jurisdictions, noting that many divergences stem from varying levels of consumer protection (for example the EU imposes a high threshold of protection, while this is limited elsewhere). Hong Kong and Singapore were identified as especially arbitration-friendly jurisdictions for crypto-related disputes.
Following the session, a reverse debate was conducted by Valentine Chessa (MCL Arbitration).
Insights on the Updated ICCA Report on Gender Diversity
Carolyn Lamm (White & Case) introduced the 2026 updated ICCA Report on gender diversity. She reviewed the progress achieved in the area of diversity. The most significant figure concerned the increase in female appointments, rising from 12.8% in 2015 to 25.3% in 2024. According to the speaker, diversity enhances the quality of decision-making, broadens the range of perspectives available within arbitral tribunals, and strengthens the legitimacy of the system. Diversity was presented not only as an issue of inclusion but also as one of effectiveness. Lamm explained that the report, released in final form on the day of the conference as the third edition after those of 2020 and 2022, shows that institutions are leading the way: in 2024 nearly half of the arbitrators appointed by the LCIA Court, the ICC and the SCC were women, while the share of women among party-appointed co-arbitrators and chairs rose only from 10% to 30.5%. In her view, the obstacles are behavioural and structural rather than a matter of awareness: reliance on word of mouth, reluctance to appoint first-time arbitrators and unconscious bias. She urged practitioners to look at a broader slate of candidates when making appointments, including expert witnesses, where women remain under-represented.
Panel II – What Remedies?
Carlevaris moderated the afternoon session, exploring remedies in international dispute resolution in the present days.
Alberto Fortún (Cuatrecasas) analysed disputes arising in contracts involving public entities within contexts of significant geopolitical and economic instability, with particular reference to the Ibero-Latin American region. He emphasized how delays, cost increases, inflation, logistical difficulties, and regulatory changes may undermine the economic balance of projects. In such circumstances, contractors tend to seek price adjustments, contractual rebalancing, or termination, whereas public authorities are generally focused on completion of the project under the original conditions. Fortún stressed the importance of the applicable law, stabilization clauses, and clear provisions governing payments and currencies, and he recommended detailed contracts, dispute-management mechanisms operating during project execution, and expressly defined arbitral powers.
Hamed Hassan Merah (Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration) described developments in Saudi law following the entry into force of the new Civil Transactions Law, presenting it as a decisive step toward greater predictability and legal certainty. He explained that Saudi law recognizes the principle of full compensation, including both actual losses and loss of profits, and permits liquidated damages clauses provided that they do not amount to interest on monetary debts. In his presentation, he focused on the distinction between force majeure and hardship: the former relates to impossibility of performance resulting from external causes, while the latter concerns obligations that remain capable of performance but have become excessively onerous. According to Merah, this distinction is particularly useful in a context marked by international sanctions, currency volatility, and supply-chain disruptions.
Olena Perepelynska (Perepelynska) described the Ukrainian experience developed through more than a decade of crises, from the annexation of Crimea to the pandemic and the ongoing full-scale war. She discussed the concept of a ”fundamental change of circumstances“ under Ukrainian law, broadly analogous to hardship, which in exceptional cases allows a contract to be amended or terminated when unforeseen events radically alter its equilibrium. She observed that wars, logistical blockades, currency restrictions, and sanctions may satisfy these requirements, although only if supported by rigorous evidentiary proof. She further noted that force majeure is frequently invoked in contracts relating to defence and international supply arrangements, but that reliance on it becomes increasingly difficult where the relevant risks were foreseeable at the time of contract formation. In her view, modern contracts must contain significantly more detailed provisions governing all the above forms of geopolitical instability.
Conclusion: Arbitration in a Changing Global Landscape
IAD 2026 highlighted that globalization is entering a new phase. Geopolitical tensions, the transformation of value chains and the evolution of international law do not signal the end of global economic integration, but rather its redefinition. The speakers emphasized that the growing level of global uncertainty makes the availability of neutral and reliable ADR mechanisms more important than ever. In this context, international arbitration continues to represent one of the most effective tools for ensuring predictability, stability, and trust in cross-border economic relations. In this environment, arbitration performs a stabilizing function and provides continuity as economic actors continue to demand legal predictability and neutrality even during periods of significant instability.
You may also like