ICC Highly Expedited Arbitration Clauses: A Useful Addition in Share Purchase Agreements?

H

The 2026 International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”) Arbitration Rules (the “2026 ICC Rules”) introduce a new procedural option that will likely attract the attention of transactional lawyers: the Highly Expedited Arbitration Provisions (“HEAP”) (already discussed here). While early commentary on the recent ICC Rules revision highlighted HEAP as a general innovation in arbitral procedure, the focus of this post is more specific. It analyses whether HEAP can be a useful tool for selected categories of post-M&A disputes arising out of share purchase agreements (“SPAs”).

This post does not argue that HEAP should become the default dispute resolution mechanism for SPAs. HEAP is neither a faster version of ordinary ICC arbitration for all purposes, nor is it the next step after the existing Expedited Procedure Provisions (“EPP”). Rather, HEAP offers a more radical opt-in tool. It is therefore worth discussing whether it may work well for certain discrete, document-based and time-sensitive disputes under an SPA.

 

What HEAP Does

Article 33 and Appendix VI of the 2026 ICC Rules provide that HEAP applies only where all parties agree. Unlike the EPP, it has no monetary threshold and no automatic application.

Once triggered, HEAP substantially compresses the arbitral process. The final award must be rendered within three months from the initial case management conference. The Request for Arbitration must include the Statement of Claim, and the Answer must include the Statement of Defence and any counterclaims. The case is heard by a sole arbitrator who is appointed directly by the ICC International Court of Arbitration (“ICC Court”) if the parties do not jointly nominate one in time.

The sole arbitrator may limit written submissions, exclude or restrict document production, limit witness or expert evidence, and decide the case on the documents without a hearing. Evidence should be submitted upfront, to the extent possible. Joinder and consolidation are excluded, but counterclaims remain possible. The parties may also agree that the award need not state reasons (for potential enforcement difficulties, see here).

These features make HEAP attractive where speed is more important than procedural depth. They also make it risky where the facts are contested, expert evidence or substantial witness evidence is required, or multiple parties and contracts are involved.

 

Where HEAP May Fit in SPAs

SPAs can generate very different kinds of disputes. HEAP should be considered only for urgent subject-matters that are not fact-heavy or document-intensive and do not require deep evidence taking.

The first category of disputes possibly suitable for HEAP comprises purchase price adjustment disputes. Typical disputes concern completion accounts, working capital adjustments, leakage claims under locked-box mechanisms, or other parts of a contractually defined price adjustment formula. The underlying issue is often one of contract interpretation whether a particular item should be included in debt, working capital, cash, leakage, transaction expenses or a similar concept. That type of question may be suitable for a fast, paper-based process.

HEAP may also work for certain earn-out disputes, but only with reservations. If the earn-out depends on agreed metrics – like revenue, EBITDA, customer numbers or other objectively recorded figures – and the dispute is about interpreting those metrics or applying them to available data, HEAP may be appropriate. If, however, the dispute concerns allegations that the buyer manipulated the business to depress the earn-out, breached conduct covenants or failed to use reasonable efforts, the case will likely become more complex and require witness evidence and document production.

Escrow release disputes are another possible category. If funds are held in escrow pending expiry of a claim period, delivery of specified documents, completion of a milestone or satisfaction of a defined condition, a short HEAP arbitration may help the parties to complete the transaction without leaving funds blocked for months or years. Similarly, milestone payments in acquisition-related or transitional arrangements may be HEAP-suitable where performance is objectively documented.

Warranty claims require a more cautious assessment. A claim for breach of a warranty that a specified permit exists, a particular receivable is outstanding, or a specific liability is absent may be relatively straightforward. By contrast, claims involving broad warranties, knowledge qualifiers, disclosure schedules, fraud allegations, management conduct, accounting judgments or regulatory issues rarely appear suitable. Those disputes often require reconstructing complex fact patterns, testing credibility and obtaining expert evidence.

Many SPAs already combine a general arbitration clause with an expert determination mechanism for these dispute categories. The parties want certainty about the purchase price quickly and may view a financial expert as better placed than lawyers to decide accounting-driven questions. Yet, the core of the dispute often lies not in the interpretation of numbers or balance sheets but in the interpretation of contract language, which is a primarily legal exercise. At least in Germany, this dichotomy often leads to lengthy disputes about whether the financial expert or the arbitral tribunal is competent to decide the disputed issue, or to follow-on arbitrations on whether the expert report is binding upon the parties. HEAP may operate either as an alternative to expert determination clauses in SPAs or as a fast follow-on mechanism to decide whether an expert determination is binding.

 

Drafting HEAP Clauses in SPAs

Drafting good arbitration clauses is not easy. Complex contractual agreements like SPAs rarely generate only one type of dispute. The same agreement may give rise to simple HEAP-suitable disputes and complex disputes that are not. At signing, the parties do not know which category will matter later. The two types of disputes can even coincide in a single case. A seller may bring a price adjustment claim suitable for HEAP, while the buyer may respond with a counterclaim or set-off that is not. The HEAP rules allow the parties to agree, or the ICC Court to decide, that HEAP no longer applies, but the parties should not rely on that safety valve in a conflict situation.

Therefore, contrary to what the ICC HEAP model clause might suggest, a blanket clause providing that all disputes in connection with an SPA shall be resolved under HEAP is not advisable. Rather, HEAP may be useful in SPAs only as a targeted device for selected parts of the contract. A HEAP opt-in clause should thus be tailored and category-specific. It should identify the disputes to which HEAP applies and leave all others to ordinary ICC arbitration or to the EPP where applicable. For example, it might apply only to disputes concerning completion accounts, leakage, escrow release, specified milestone payments or certain aspects of an earn-out mechanism.

The clause should also carefully define the interface and boundaries between HEAP, ordinary or EPP arbitration, and any expert determination, pre-arbitral negotiation or mediation. To avoid mixing HEAP-suitable and non-HEAP claims in one arbitration, the parties may exclude non-HEAP counterclaims and set-offs from a HEAP arbitration, leaving them for a separate arbitration. Alternatively, they may agree that such a counterclaim or set-off is admissible but triggers the discontinuation of HEAP under Article 1(2) of Appendix VI. If so, the parties should decide in advance whether the sole arbitrator appointed for HEAP remains in office. Where HEAP is combined with expert determination with the goal of producing a binding arbitral award on preliminary contract interpretation issues on which the expert’s determination shall be based, the parties may agree on safeguards in their HEAP clause to combine all open interpretation issues in one HEAP arbitration, thereby avoiding multiple HEAP arbitrations.

Finally, as HEAP leaves little room for procedural disputes over basics, the seat and language of arbitration should be defined. If the parties contemplate an award without reasons, they should check whether that is permissible at the seat and whether it may create enforcement difficulties in likely enforcement jurisdictions.

 

A Useful Tool, If Used Wisely

In conclusion, HEAP is not a general solution to the cost and duration of post-M&A arbitration. It is too compressed for many SPA disputes. However, it may be highly effective for a narrow class of disputes where the facts are documented, the issue is self-contained, and speed has real commercial value. For those categories of disputes in SPAs for which a three-month ICC award would be better than expert determination, ordinary arbitration or the EPP, HEAP can be a valuable addition to the drafting toolkit. However, because of the complexities of SPAs and the difficult interface problems between HEAP, ordinary or EPP arbitration, and potential other dispute resolution mechanisms, HEAP is a tool for experienced transactional lawyers and parties who know how to use it wisely.

Comments (0)
Your email address will not be published.
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published.
Clear all
Become a contributor!
Become a contributor Contact Editorial Guidelines