A Blue Moon over Brazil: Superior Court of Justice Opens Brazilian Courts' Doors to the Annulment of a Foreign Arbitral Award

Brazil

Whether out of legal strategy or simply free choice, the parties’ capacity to decide keeps challenging structures that seemed to be settled. In international arbitration, party autonomy is usually the element that unsettles a landscape of apparent solidity.

Consider the following choices. Two parties agreed on ICC arbitration in New York, chose Brazilian law to govern both the contract and the arbitration and – in an unusual move – elected the courts of São Paulo/Brazil, to the exclusion of any other, to hear any annulment action. An award was rendered in New York. The losing party went exactly where the contract told it to go: São Paulo. The São Paulo Court of Appeals closed the door.

Gary Born (International Commercial Arbitration, 3rd ed., 2021) calls annulment outside the seat, under the second limb of Article V(1)(e), a "once-in-a-blue-moon" occurrence. The question, then, is simple to ask and was, until now, unanswered in Brazilian case law: can parties choose Brazil as the forum to annul an arbitral award that is deemed “foreign” under Brazilian law?

On 6 October 2026, the blue moon rose over Brazil. In REsp 2.224.272/SP, the Third Panel of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) unanimously answered yes to that question. It is the first time the Court has said so. And, contrary to what a hasty reading might suggest, this is not Brazil reaching out to annul more. It is Brazil choosing to honor both the parties’ choice and the New York Convention, which was ratified and internalized by Decree No. 4,311/2002.

 

The Case: When the Choice Is Put to the Test

The dispute arose from the sale of Banco Industrial e Comercial (BicBanco) by members of the Bezerra family to the China Construction Bank (CCB). The whole case, for the purposes of the judgment recently rendered by the STJ, lies in the arbitration clause, which established the following criteria: Clause 10.4 places the arbitration in New York; Clause 10.6 provides that "the arbitration shall comply with the laws of the Federative Republic of Brazil", so Brazilian law is the lex arbitri, not just the law of the contract; and Clause 10.12 then elects the courts of São Paulo, "to the exclusion of any other", for a closed list of court matters, expressly including the annulment action under Article 32 of the Brazilian Arbitration Act.

The arbitral tribunal issued a partial award in CCB's favor, holding that a contractual gross-up obligation was not subject to a monetary cap. The sellers invoked the forum clause and sought annulment in São Paulo on three grounds under Article 32 (III, IV and VIII) – among them, that the arbitral tribunal went beyond the limits of the arbitration agreement.

The lower court rejected CCB's objection to jurisdiction, but the São Paulo State Court of Appeals (TJSP) reversed the ruling, deciding that a foreign award has no effect in Brazil before the STJ recognizes it, so there would be no interest in annulling it here – forum clause or not. Meanwhile, CCB's request for recognition (HDE 8.716) awaits judgment before the STJ's Special Court.

 

The Superior Court of Justice Decides: Two Keys, One Door

The judgment spanned two sessions. On 1 September 2026, the reporting Justice, Nancy Andrighi, voted to recognize Brazilian jurisdiction, but Justice Ricardo Villas Bôas Cueva took the case under advisement. The judgment concluded on 6 October 2026, with a unanimous Panel. The case now returns to the TJSP to decide the annulment on the merits.

The Court did not throw out the rule. Jurisdiction is an expression of sovereignty: the seat exercises primary control over an award's validity, while the country of enforcement exercises secondary control through recognition. What the STJ did was find a door the rule itself leaves ajar – one that opens only with two keys turned together:

1.   a forum-selection clause choosing Brazilian courts for the annulment action; and

2.   the coincidence between that forum and the lex arbitri – Brazilian law governing the arbitration itself.

The first key is party autonomy. Article 22(III) of the Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure – the provision that makes Brazil an "open doors" system in matters of jurisdiction – recognizes the parties' submission to Brazilian courts.

The second key – the decisive one – is the lex arbitri, and this is where the drafting made all the difference. The parties chose Brazilian law as the lex arbitri (clause 10.6) and reinforced that choice by naming Article 32 of the Brazilian Arbitration Act for the annulment action. They were free to do so. Article 2(1) of the Act allows parties to "freely choose the rules of law" applicable to the arbitration – an "opening in the system", in Justice Cueva's words. And, as he noted, nothing prevents parties from departing from the law of the seat, a possibility the New York Convention itself contemplates in Article V(1)(e). If the parties may choose the law governing the arbitration proceeding, and the Convention names that country as an annulment forum, the seat cannot be the only place where an award can be set aside.

Article V(1)(e) speaks of annulment in the country "in which, or under the law of which" the award was made. The Court read those words as the UNCITRAL Secretariat Guide reads them: as referring to the procedural law chosen by the parties, where it differs from the seat’s. The STJ states plainly in the headnote that the second limb covers the country whose "procedural law (lex arbitri)" was applied, so choosing Brazilian law for the procedure, "even with a foreign seat, opens the doors of the national judiciary to the annulment action".

With both keys turned, "there is no reason not to recognize Brazilian jurisdiction", wrote Justice Cueva. Nor does public policy stand in the way: the Arbitration Act does not forbid the choice, and the Convention, part of Brazilian law through Decree No. 4,311/2002, recognises it "if only indirectly".

And the TJSP's objection – no effect, no interest? The headnote rejects it expressly, and the answer lies in separating two planes. The STJ described an "active route" (annulment, which goes to validity) and a "passive route" (refusal of recognition, which goes to effects in Brazil). A foreign award is final and binding the moment it is rendered; recognition merely lends it the State's coercive power.

 

Open Doors, Not Open System

Does this make Brazil eager to annul foreign awards? Absolutely not.

First, the door is narrow. The New York Convention admits only two annulment forums: the seat of arbitration and the State whose law governs the procedure. A forum clause alone would not do; had the parties chosen New York law to govern the arbitration and Brazilian courts only for the annulment, the clause would most likely have been disregarded, since the Convention recognizes no annulment forum in Brazil in that scenario. And since the 2024 amendment to Article 63 of the Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 14,879/2024), which requires a forum clause to relate to a party's domicile or the place of the obligation, only deals with a real Brazilian connection get through. Tellingly, Justice Andrighi used the hearing to regret the growing number of annulment actions – and still recognized Brazilian jurisdiction. After all, jurisdiction exists because the parties created it.

Second, closing the door would not have protected arbitration; it would have left a vacuum. In an expert opinion filed in the case, Professor George Bermann stated that a New York court would defer to the exclusive São Paulo forum – and the US deadline had long passed. Recognition is no substitute: Article 32 offers broader grounds than the recognition defenses, and only one of the three invoked here has a counterpart there. Had CCB never sought recognition in Brazil, the sellers would have had no forum at all – or would have needed what counsel aptly called a "de-recognition".

Third, the decision says something about how Brazil sees arbitration. In Emmanuel Gaillard's three representations, the territorialist approach anchors an award solely in the legal order of the seat; the Westphalian view sees a plurality of State legal orders, none bound by the seat's verdict; the transnational view detaches arbitration from any State. The TJSP stood in the first. The STJ moved Brazil to the second. That is not Brazil pulling arbitration back home. It is Brazil accepting that awards live in a world of many legal orders – the very world the New York Convention was built for.

 

Conclusion: Hold On to Your Choice

So, back to the question: can parties choose Brazil as the forum to annul a foreign award? Yes, when they clearly choose both the forum and Brazilian law to govern the arbitration.

The STJ did not create a new route to challenge foreign awards. It recognized one the parties had built themselves, with materials offered by the New York Convention and Brazilian law. Party autonomy, which legitimizes arbitration from the very start, was respected to the very end – including in the choice of who may set aside the award.

An earlier post about this case ended with a lesson: to avoid jurisdictional headaches, "you better hold on to your seat". It still holds – but it is no longer the only one. In Brazil, you may also hold on to your choice.

Disclosure: The authors are part of the counsel team for the appellants (the sellers) in REsp 2.224.272/SP, together with other lawyers from Wald, Antunes, Vita e Blattner Advogados and lawyers from Cescon, Barrieu, Flesch & Barreto Advogados; Panella Advogados; Hamid Bdine Advogados; and Salomão Advogados. The views expressed are the authors' own and do not necessarily reflect those of their firm or its clients.

Comments (0)
Your email address will not be published.
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published.
Clear all
Become a contributor!
Become a contributor Contact Editorial Guidelines