Permanent injunctions granted in 94 per cent of the patent decisions examined. Proportionality expressly assessed in 0.6 per cent. Since January these two figures, taken from the executive summary of…
A failed FRAND negotiation does not end when the parties leave the room. By then they have exchanged claim charts, discussed comparable licenses and moved some distance from their opening positions…
The disclosure decision comes firstA comparable licence is never only evidence of a rate. Before the Unified Patent Court, pleading one may open it to an employee of the opponent, keep that employee…
A compass worth havingThe 7th Civil Chamber of the Landgericht München I has done something no European court had done before. On 13 August 2026 it published guidelines, sixty-seven pages long,…
My forthcoming book, A Contractual Theory of FRAND: From Private Normativity to Legal Obligation in Technical Standardization, starts from a question that remains insufficiently examined in standard…
At the UPC, quantum is starting to do more than compensate. A public, reasoned figure can become a reference point for licensing, valuation and settlement. The early case law also marks the limit of…
Arbitration as a Distinct Procedural ProductArbitration is more ambitious than mediation, and that ambition has a price. It promises a private, specialized, and enforceable decision rendered by…
Abstract:FRAND licensing asks implementers to pay today for a benchmark that courts may only define tomorrow – often in disputes to which they were not a party. When later decisions show that agreed…
In contemporary SEP litigation, debates about FRAND almost always open with the same questions. What is the correct royalty rate? Which licences should count as comparables? Should the rate be global…